Scarcity or Abundance? (John 10:15; COD Head 2)
Introduction
Limited atonement sounds as if the Lord is setting up an excluvie group or there is not enough for everyone. Far from portraying Christ’s atonement as scarce or exclusive, Scripture presents it as infinitely sufficient for the whole human race. However, Christ’s work is only applied to the sheep. So, Christ’s work is not a scarce resource, but it is only applied to the elect. This is not something for the elite because none of us deserve Christ’s work. We are all sewer dwellers who need to be lifted up by the scruff of our necks.
Who Are the Sheep?
John 10 divides humanity into two groups: Christ’s sheep and those who are not His sheep. Christ lays down His life for His sheep. The Canons of Dordt teach us that Christ’s death is infinitely sufficient. This means that if the human race continued to generate generations forever that Christ could save ever last one of them. However, God chose only to apply Christ’s work to his sheep or his elect people.
These sheep are not identified by elite status or by receiving mystical confirmation of election. Jesus explains that His sheep are simply those who hear His voice, and follow him. How do we know if we heard his voice? Do you believe the Gospel? Do you believe that Christ is the God man? Do you believe that Christ is your savior? Well, then you are one of his sheep.
The problem with this doctrine’s title, “Limited Atonement” is we think we know the number of the elect. However, we have no idea how many people will be in heaven. It is not for us to know. We are simply called to preach the gospel, call Christ’s sheep, and follow his lead as faithful sheep.
What Does It Mean That Christ Lays Down His Life for the Sheep?
Article 4 of the Canons highlights the unique value of Christ’s death: only the God-man can offer a sacrifice sufficient to satisfy God’s requirements. Christ is both truly human (creature who offended) and truly divine (able to bear the infinite wrath).
Christ is our unique savior, but the beauty of John 10 is that he is also our shepherd. His self-giving is radical. He gives his life so his sheep can have life. Christ intentionally lays down His life because this is the only way to secure His people. We do not walk in a dead shepherd, but the shepherd who also takes it up. Christ’s work definitively assures us. This is why we sometimes say that this is definite atonement.
What Does “Limited Atonement” Actually Mean?
The doctrine does not teach scarcity, insufficiency, or elitism. Instead, it affirms:
Christ’s atonement is infinite in worth and fully sufficient for all if God so chose. The beauty of this is that Christ’s sheep not only will hear his voice, but they will obey. As they obey their shepherd they will be lead into the heavenly pastures.
Assurance comes through believing Christ, not by calculating how many are saved or whether the “supply” of atonement has run out. Christ knows His sheep, calls them, gives them eternal life, and promises that no one can snatch them from His hand.
Conclusion
We need to remember that the doctrine of limited atonement or definite atonement is not meant to unsettle believers but to anchor them. Christ never reveals the number of the redeemed or invites us to speculate on who is in the flock. Rather, He directs us to one simple question: Do you hear the Shepherd’s voice and believe the gospel? If so, His atonement is yours, His life is yours, and His protection is yours. The doctrine is therefore not restrictive but profoundly comforting: the Good Shepherd lays down His life with purpose, gathers His sheep across history, and guarantees that His sheep will dwell with him him in glory. Let us hear the voice of our shepherd. Let us walk in the Good Shepherd, who not only laid down his life, but who also took it up again.